Tula Benefits← All notes
Regulation

It isn't really about cutting commissions

Meenu Singh · 5 October 2026

Everybody is talking about IRDAI's new consultation paper and how it squeezes the non-insurance and non-TPA stakeholders. But if you take the effort to read it through, it isn't really about cutting commissions. It's about closing a loophole the industry built for itself.

In 2023-24, IRDAI replaced rigid product-level commission caps with one flexible rule: pay whatever you want, as long as total expenses of management (EoM) stay under an overall ceiling of 30% for general insurers and 35% for health insurers.

Reasonable idea. It didn't survive contact with the market.

The regulator's own data in its September 2026 consultation paper puts a number on the mechanism. In a sample covering about 92% of life insurance sold through corporate agents (mostly banks), new business premium grew 28% between FY23 and FY25, while distributor remuneration grew 125%. Payouts grew more than four times faster than the business that was supposed to justify them. That isn't a pricing anomaly. It's what happens when commission is set by how easy something is to sell, not by how much effort or expertise it needs.

Freedom at product level, with a cap only at aggregate level, creates one rational move: overpay commission on whatever is easiest to sell (the simplest, highest-volume products) and let the blended average absorb it.

The September 2026 proposal doesn't scrap flexible EoM. It puts the guardrails back inside it:

The market priced it in at once. Distribution stocks fell sharply the week the paper came out.

2023-24 was "trust the aggregate and let the market self-correct". The market didn't self-correct. It optimised around the gap. 2026 is the regulator going back in with sharper tools: product-level discipline, a lower ceiling, and visibility into every rupee of payout.

For anyone who still earns through commission, the economics just got tighter and the conflict of interest got harder to hide. For anyone advising clients on a fee, paid the same whichever insurer or product the client chooses, this is the moment that argument stops being a nice-to-have and becomes the whole pitch.

Source: IRDAI consultation paper on insurance distribution, September 2026. First published on LinkedIn, 5 October 2026.

Tula BenefitsIndependent advice on employee benefits in India for international companies, Global Capability Centres and growing firms. [email protected] · tulabenefits.com