Tula Benefits← All notes
Regulation

Why is the employer missing from the commission debate?

Meenu Singh · 7 October 2026

The employer pays for group health. So why is the employer missing from the commission debate?

Insurers, intermediaries and the regulator are all being heard on IRDAI's distribution paper. The company that funds the policy mostly is not.

I think the paper points in the right direction, and its own data makes the case. For group health, the industry average commission is 12%, comparable to individual health at 17%. The paper calls this "counter-intuitive", because group policies have high claims ratios and group buyers can negotiate (Part 2, para 2.1.6). The proposal would cap it at 2.5% for distribution entities (Box 4A).

But a cap of that size needs numbers behind it.

Look at how the paper plans to judge the caps. The outcome measures for this objective are commission paid by insurers and received by distributors, by product, line and channel. They count rupees leaving the insurer. None of them measures what reaches the employer: the premium it pays, the service its employees get, the claims they are paid.

After eleven years across retail insurance and employee benefits, my view is simple. When the insurer pays the adviser, the system pulls even good advisers away from the client's long-term cost. That is a design problem, not a people problem.

So, in response to Consultation Question 31, I'd suggest the impact assessment uses four lenses:

  1. Revenue: does a lower distribution cost show up in the employer's premium?
  2. Penetration: do small and medium employers still get attention?
  3. Jobs: what happens to the people who do servicing and claims support?
  4. Opportunities: what new models, such as fee-based advice, open up?

I'm no longer a broker. I speak for the employer, using the data in IRDAI's own paper.

If you run HR or finance for a growing company, what would you want IRDAI to measure?

Source: IRDAI consultation paper on insurance distribution, September 2026. First published on LinkedIn, 7 October 2026.

Tula BenefitsIndependent advice on employee benefits in India for international companies, Global Capability Centres and growing firms. [email protected] · tulabenefits.com